Dying Every Day

Dying Every Day

👁️ The Wisdom of Wonder

Know Thyself (Vol. 3)

J.W. Bertolotti's avatar
J.W. Bertolotti
Jun 20, 2025
∙ Paid

Dear Readers,

A quick note: As always, thank you for reading and supporting this newsletter! If you missed the previous volumes, check out The Philosophy of Desire (Vol. 1) and The Self, Shadow, and Sage (Vol. 2). If you have questions, thoughts, or suggestions, please feel free to share in the comments.

Be wise and be well.

Study of Clouds by John Constable (Public domain)

Never stop learning how to live!

👁️ Know Thyself

The “Know Thyself” series explores philosophy, theology, and psychology for insights on the art (and science) of self-awareness. Expect to learn perennial ideas and psychological concepts on human nature, along with philosophical lessons on the art of living.



The Wisdom of Wonder

Humans are inherently curious from birth. As soon as we start speaking, we ask questions like “Why?”—about the nature, meaning, and origin of things. This curiosity is not a defect or something to outgrow; it shows that we are creatures driven by a desire for understanding. In essence, wonder reflects a fundamental aspect of human nature: that we are all seekers.

Across different traditions, wonder serves as both the beginning and the essence of philosophy. In this essay, we will explore three main aspects of wonder: first, as the basis for philosophical inquiry; second, as a distinctive method of understanding; and third, as a spiritual or philosophical practice.

1. The Origin of Philosophy

Philosophy does not start with certainty but with wonder. The Greeks termed this amazement “thaumazein”—a profound sense of awe.

The Greek philosopher Aristotle writes:

It is owing to their wonder that men both now begin and at first began to philosophize.

For Aristotle, wonder isn't just a passive feeling; it's the driving force behind inquiry. It stimulates the mind to explore a world that is understandable but always has more to discover.

Plato echoes this idea when Socrates states:

This sense of wonder is the mark of the philosopher. Philosophy indeed has no other origin.

Wonder is not the lack of knowledge but the very condition that allows knowledge to exist. It shakes complacency and awakens the soul.

The existential philosopher Martin Heidegger elaborates on this idea in Introduction to Metaphysics, stating that wonder isn't about specific facts but about being itself: “The feeling of wonder is nothing less than the astonishment at the fact that beings are—and not nothing.”

This ontological astonishment extends beyond mere curiosity, transforming our relationship with existence.

Even in modern ethics, wonder retains its formative power. The American philosopher Martha Nussbaum, in her work on the emotions, observes:

Wonder is the basis of respect. Without wonder, we become morally numb.

Thus, wonder is not just an intellectual start—it is a moral awakening. It undermines the illusion of mastery and reveals the inherent dignity of others and the world itself.

If wonder is where philosophy begins, then it also resists finality. And in that refusal to conclude, it opens up a deeper form of knowing.


Two Poor Men Sleeping by Isidre Nonell (1897)

2. The Art of Knowing

Wonder is frequently misinterpreted as the opposite of knowledge, viewed as childish or irrational. However, numerous philosophers and psychologists contend that wonder is not a rejection of understanding but rather its most profound source.

In contemporary scientific terms, to know something typically means to define, predict, or control it. In contrast, wonder defies such simplification. The French Catholic philosopher Jacques Maritain suggests:

To wonder is not to doubt. It is to be amazed at a mystery, fully real, that one feels is intelligible though beyond one's grasp.

In essence, wonder is not simply ignorance; it reflects a deep reverence for an intelligibility that surpasses our ability to fully grasp it.

Philosopher and theologian Rudolf Otto, in his exploration of the divine experience, called this the mysterium tremendum et fascinans—a mystery that simultaneously captivates and overwhelms us. While he focused on the sacred, his insight resonates with all instances of wonder.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of J.W. Bertolotti.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 J.W. Bertolotti · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture