Dying Daily—Meditations for Mortals
The idea comes from Seneca: we die a little each day, and the awareness of that fact is the beginning. Dying Daily is a series of short meditations for mortals—on what to attend to, how to live deliberately, and how to remember to live.
Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, ...
Socrates on Trusting Your Inner Voice
Dying Daily—Meditations for Mortals
Socrates described a strange experience at his trial. He said that since childhood, a divine sign had sometimes restrained him from doing something he was about to do. In Plato’s account, it offered no program for his life. It only warned him not to go on.
Socrates understood this restraint as divine.
In the Apology, he says:
“It always holds me back from what I am thinking of doing, but never urges me forward.”
The passage leaves us with a question about restraint.
What should we do when something within us hesitates? Hesitation can be right, and it can stop us. It can also be fear of embarrassment, reluctance to change, or an old prejudice that has acquired the sound of certainty.
A feeling does not arrive labeled with its source. Introspection has limits. We mistake confidence for knowledge and uneasiness for evidence.
Epictetus offers a discipline for this: test an impression before accepting what it presents as true or good. Where Socrates reports a divine warning, Epictetus asks for examination. The two disagree about where a trustworthy voice comes from.
Suppose you hesitate before speaking against an unfair decision.
You may have noticed a consequence others missed. You also fear becoming unpopular. The hesitation alone cannot decide between them. Ask what you expect to happen, what supports that expectation, and what your silence would cost the person affected.
Later in the Apology comes the sign’s most famous moment: silence.
After the jury condemns him to death, Socrates says the sign never once opposed him that day: not when he left home, not when he came to court, and not at any point in his speech. He takes its silence as evidence that what lies ahead may not be an evil at all.
We need not share his reading to learn from it.
He had spent a lifetime attending to what the sign did and did not do, and so could hear its silence as well as its warnings. That is the education conscience needs: not blind trust, but long acquaintance, tested against evidence and against the lives our choices touch.
After the pause, someone may still need you to speak, with reasons you can explain and doubts you are willing to admit.
Waiting for certainty is itself a decision about what you are willing to allow.
Daily Practice
Notice one hesitation today, a moment when something in you says not yet, or not this. Before obeying or overriding it, name what it might be protecting you from, and what it might be sparing you from having to do.
Then decide, ready to explain your choice to the person it affects.
Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, ...
—
Thank you for reading; I hope you found something useful.
Until next time, remember to live.
J.W.
P.S. If you found today’s meditation helpful, please consider sharing it.