Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Simon Parritt's avatar

Thank you for this reflection on Socrates. I read it not only as a very uninformed but interested reader of philosophy and psychologist, but also as someone who lives every day since a child with disability and now in the autumn of my life also prostate cancer. I stand therefore on both sides—as clinician and as patient.

For me, the struggle is not only with fear of illness, pain, loss and death, which is not unique or really avoidable, but with the systems and people around me who so often act out of fear rather than virtue.

They follow procedure, protect themselves, and yet believe they are acting rightly. That is perhaps the hardest trial: not death itself, but facing death in the midst of institutions and sadly people who fail to live up to Socrates’ standard of virtue. Indeed often fail to recognise that it is at the heart of everything that gives meaning to life and that it is sometimes enough to just recognise that and aim for it, even if we fail. Intention is I feel a virtue in itself.

Gandolfo Corradino's avatar

Outstanding essay! And to think that Socrates died 399 BC and we are still asking the same two questions Socrates raised. And we don’t have definitive answers. That’s not to say some people don’t have a faith system that gives them an answer. But it is ultimately just an opinion. Because it can’t be proved. BecauseFaith is believing in something that can’t be proved. Thank you so much for this translating this pod cast.

No posts

Ready for more?